Leaders once drew authority from scarce expertise. AI now produces analysis, options and recommendations on demand.
So what do leaders add? Judgement, meaning and a willingness to stand behind a decision. Those are what people follow.
AI advice is uneven
Dell'Acqua and colleagues found consultants using AI did better on tasks within its capability. On a task outside it, they were 19 percentage points less likely to reach the right answer.
Most workers already sense this. Microsoft's 2026 Work Trend Index found 86% of AI users treat its output as a starting point.
Someone still has to decide when the recommendation fits. That is a leadership job.
Three capabilities that matter more
Judgement. Ask whether a recommendation fits your situation, what it misses and when to override it.
Making meaning. Data informs, and stories move people. Explain what a recommendation means for them and what it asks of them.
Conviction. Sometimes values or long-term goals point away from the data. Be willing to say so, and explain why.
Build this capability in your organisation
Growth Performance designs bespoke programmes that turn insight into measurable behaviour change.
Influence when facts are cheap
People can now check what leaders say against AI in seconds. Authority built on knowing facts weakens. Authority built on trust, fairness and clear reasoning grows.
Haslam, Reicher and Platow argue that leaders gain influence by representing and advancing what their group cares about. That matters more when answers are easy to find.
Leaders also shape how their teams use AI. Microsoft found that when managers model AI use, trust in AI agents is 30 points higher.
Leading openly with AI builds Adoption.
Practise the new influence
Record your judgement calls. Before accepting or overriding an AI recommendation, note what it says, what your instinct says and why. Review the notes every few months.
Ask "so what?" For each insight, ask what it means, why people should care and what should change.
Understand your tools. Know what data a tool uses, where it is weak and when it might be wrong.
Try this
For the next AI recommendation you receive, write three lines before deciding: the recommendation, your instinct and the reason for it. Compare them with the outcome a month later.
Then take the free Influencing Without Authority assessment.
