Skip to main content
    Back to The Human Advantage
    Adaptation
    6 min read14 November 2026

    Whether people can direct, combine and check AI agents in real work.

    The leadership readiness gap: what leaders and employees report differently

    The short answer

    Leaders consistently report more AI readiness than employees feel. In the 2026 Wharton study, 78% of leaders called AI training adequate against 56% of employees. SHRM found communication and trust fall the further people are from the top. The gap is about support and clarity more than enthusiasm.

    Ben George

    Founder & Director

    Ask a senior team whether the organisation is ready for AI and you will often hear yes. Ask the people doing the work and the answer is less certain.

    Several 2026 studies now measure that gap directly. The figures differ by source, but the pattern holds: leaders see more readiness than employees feel.

    This article sets out what the studies show, where they disagree, and what leaders can do about it.

    Training: leaders think it is done

    The Wharton and GBK Collective study was fielded in July 2026 and published in October 2026. It surveyed 1,416 people in US enterprises, and for the first time compared leaders with entry and mid-career employees.

    78% of leaders said AI training is adequate. Only 56% of employees agreed.

    GBK Collective, a commercial research firm, designed and ran the study. That does not undermine the finding, but it is worth knowing.

    SHRM's survey of 5,875 US workers, fielded in March and April 2026, adds detail. Of the 4,065 who use or have used AI at work, 69% describe their experience as none, beginner or intermediate.

    Communication: the further from the top, the later people hear

    SHRM asked whether people heard about AI before it reached their work. 74% of directors and above said yes, compared with 55% of managers and 1 in 3 individual contributors.

    Trust in senior leaders on AI was 61% overall. Among individual contributors it was 47%.

    Early-career professionals feel a different pressure: 45% report pressure to use AI in their roles.

    Use and value: leaders are further ahead

    Gallup's 2026 data show frequent AI use rising at every grade since 2023. As of the second quarter of 2026, 51% of leaders use AI frequently, up from 17%. For managers it is 36%, up from 15%, and for individual contributors 26%, up from 9%.

    Leaders also report stronger results. 21% of leaders say the effect on productivity has been extremely positive, compared with 13% of individual contributors.

    When leaders use AI more and see more value, it is easy to assume everyone else is in the same place.

    Readiness: even leaders have doubts

    McKinsey's State of Organizations 2026 offers a useful counterweight. Its survey of 10,018 senior executives ran from June to September 2025, and the report was published in February 2026, so the data are older than the others here.

    Even among leaders, 72% said their organisations are not fully ready for upcoming changes. 86% said they are not very prepared to adopt AI in day-to-day operations.

    Only 14% of organisations see leaders consistently championing AI adoption with clear strategies and action.

    Build this capability in your organisation

    Growth Performance designs bespoke programmes that turn insight into measurable behaviour change.

    Explore Adaptation

    Where the sources disagree

    The studies do not tell one tidy story. Wharton found that 80% of leaders report positive returns from AI, yet only 7% meet all three of its markers of success. 73% of employees say AI has had a positive effect on their role.

    So employees are not simply sceptical. Many value AI in their own work while doubting the training, communication and support around it.

    Microsoft's 2026 Work Trend Index adds that only 1 in 4 respondents see their leadership as clearly aligned on AI. Microsoft sells AI tools, and its figures are self-reported.

    The honest reading is that the gap is about support and clarity more than enthusiasm.

    What the gap costs

    A readiness gap is not only a matter of perception. When leaders believe training is done, budgets move on. When employees feel unprepared, they either avoid AI or use it quietly without guidance.

    Both outcomes are expensive. Avoidance means the investment is wasted. Quiet use means mistakes go unchecked and good practice is never shared.

    There is also a trust cost. If people hear about AI changes late, they start to read every announcement with suspicion.

    Questions to ask both groups

    Use the same questions for leaders, managers and teams, then compare the answers side by side.

    1. How confident are you using AI in your own work?
    2. Did you hear about the last AI change before it affected your work?
    3. Has the training you received been enough for the way you work now?
    4. How much time each week do you spend fixing AI output?
    5. Who would you ask if you were unsure whether you were allowed to use AI for a task?

    The largest differences between the groups show you where to act first.

    What managers can do this month

    Managers sit in the middle of the gap, so they can see both sides of it. Three small steps help.

    First, ask your team what they were told about the last AI change, and when. Second, pass the answers upwards, without names. Third, share one thing you learned about using AI well, so the team hears it from someone they work with every day.

    How to close the gap

    • Measure from both sides. Ask managers and their teams the same questions and compare the answers.
    • Brief managers before teams. Make sure managers hear about AI changes early enough to answer questions.
    • Treat training as ongoing. If most users rate their experience as intermediate or below, a launch course was not enough.
    • Ask about workload. Find out how much time goes on fixing AI output before you count the time saved.

    Start with two free tools. The AI Leadership Readiness Scorecard asks leaders twelve questions on how ready they are to lead with AI. The Manager Capability Heatmap maps a group of managers against fifteen behaviours.

    For the team side of readiness, see the Adaptation condition. To bring leaders and teams into one conversation, our team events for 2026 and 2027 can be built around these questions.


    Try this now

    1. Complete the AI Leadership Readiness Scorecard yourself.
    2. Ask two team members the same three questions about AI training and support.
    3. Compare your answers with theirs and note the biggest difference.

    Frequently asked questions

    What is the leadership readiness gap?

    It is the difference between how ready leaders believe the organisation is for AI and how ready employees feel. Several 2026 studies measure it, including Wharton and GBK Collective, SHRM, Gallup and McKinsey.

    Do employees dislike AI?

    Not on this evidence. Wharton found 73% of employees say AI has had a positive effect on their role. Their doubts are mostly about training, communication and support.

    How old is the McKinsey data?

    McKinsey's State of Organizations 2026 was published in February 2026, but its survey of 10,018 senior executives ran from June to September 2025, so it is older than the other studies cited.

    How can leaders close the gap?

    Ask managers and teams the same questions and compare answers, brief managers before teams, treat AI training as ongoing and measure time spent fixing AI output before counting time saved.

    Want to explore these ideas further?

    Tell us about your people and we will shape options around them.

    Get options for your team

    Trusted by McDonald's, Nissan, the NHS and Munich Re. 97% average satisfaction across 500+ programmes and workshops.Source: Growth Performance internal research data and surveys, June 2016 to June 2026.