Skip to main content

    Interactive assessment

    Honest Feedback Self-Assessment

    Assess how effectively you combine caring personally with challenging directly, the two dimensions that define high-quality leadership communication.

    The most common leadership communication failure is being too nice to be useful: caring about people so much that you withhold the honest feedback they need to grow. Effective leadership communication requires two things working together — genuine care for the person, and the courage to challenge them directly. This diagnostic helps you understand where you are strong across both dimensions and what to change to communicate with both honesty and genuine care.

    Questions or items
    20 questions or items
    Completion time
    Around 10 minutes
    Dimensions
    Caring Personally, Challenging Directly, Feedback Quality & Honesty, Building a Feedback Culture
    What you receive
    Personalised results with configured interpretation bands, section scores and development guidance.

    What it covers

    • Caring Personally
    • Challenging Directly
    • Feedback Quality & Honesty
    • Building a Feedback Culture

    Rate each statement from 1 (Strongly Disagree) to 5 (Strongly Agree) based on how you actually behave with the people you lead, not how you intend to behave. Think of specific recent interactions.

    Results: Personalised results with configured interpretation bands, section scores and development guidance.

    How this interactive diagnostic works

    This page provides the documented overview before the interactive experience is loaded. It lets you read the purpose, the material covered and the way the result is presented without entering answers or sending a request. When you choose to continue, the interactive version uses the same material shown here. It records your selections while you work and only calculates its result when its required items are complete.

    Analytics consent is required before the interactive experience is mounted. Declining consent does not start the diagnostic or its tracking. If you continue, the existing experience remains responsible for its own input, score and lead-capture step. Where the route requests a first name and work email, its existing form handles validation and submission. This overview does not replace those steps or submit a lead.

    Statements in this diagnostic

    The interactive version groups the statements below by section. Read them in relation to the situation named in the instructions, then use the response scale shown by the diagnostic. The section descriptions are part of the existing configuration and explain the aspect each group is intended to examine.

    Caring Personally

    Honest, effective leadership requires genuine investment in the people you work with, not just their performance, but their wellbeing, growth and life outside work.

    1. I invest time in understanding what motivates each person I lead, what they care about beyond their job title
    2. When someone on my team is struggling personally, I acknowledge it and offer genuine support
    3. I am interested in the long-term career and development goals of the people I lead, not just their current performance
    4. I build enough trust with my team that people feel comfortable being honest with me about how they are doing
    5. People on my team know I am in their corner, that I care about them succeeding as much as I care about hitting targets

    Challenging Directly

    Caring without challenging leads to the most common leadership failure mode: withholding honest feedback out of misplaced kindness. Honest, direct challenge is an act of respect, not aggression.

    1. I give honest, direct feedback, even when it is uncomfortable, rather than softening it to the point of uselessness
    2. When someone's work is not good enough, I tell them clearly, I do not let poor performance go unaddressed
    3. I challenge ideas I disagree with in meetings, I do not stay silent to avoid conflict
    4. I give critical feedback promptly, I do not wait for formal review cycles to address performance issues
    5. People who receive feedback from me know exactly what they need to change, my feedback is specific and actionable

    Feedback Quality & Honesty

    High-quality feedback is specific, timely, honest and delivered in a way that the other person can actually hear, it is neither vague nor brutal.

    1. My feedback is specific, I describe concrete behaviours and their impact, not general impressions
    2. I give positive feedback as readily as critical feedback, I don't only speak up when something goes wrong
    3. I deliver critical feedback in private and positive feedback in public (unless the person prefers otherwise)
    4. I check that my feedback has been understood and landed, I don't just deliver it and walk away
    5. I am honest about my own mistakes with my team, I model the receptiveness to feedback I expect from others

    Building a Feedback Culture

    The most effective leaders don't just give good feedback, they create an environment where feedback flows in all directions, including upward.

    1. I actively solicit feedback from the people I lead about how I can be a better leader, and I act on it
    2. I respond well when I receive feedback, I listen, I don't get defensive, and I follow up
    3. My team members give each other feedback regularly, not just through me or formal review processes
    4. I have created a team environment where honest challenge is welcomed rather than politically risky
    5. I reward honesty in my team, I do not, even subtly, punish people who give me feedback I don't want to hear

    How the result is read

    The interactive diagnostic totals the selected item scores by section and across the whole assessment. It then matches those totals to the configured interpretation bands and shows the section-level results alongside the overall result.

    • Significant Gaps, 20 to 44: Significant gaps in your feedback and communication approach. The most common pattern at this level is high caring but low challenging — you are being kind in the short term but withholding information people need to grow. Start with one direct feedback conversation this week.
    • Developing, 45 to 64: Developing with some inconsistency across areas. Most leaders at this level are good at one dimension but struggle with the other. Check whether your Caring Personally and Challenging Directly scores are balanced — a large gap between them reveals the root issue.
    • Capable, 65 to 82: A capable communicator who largely combines care and honesty effectively. Focus on Feedback Culture — this is where capable leaders typically have room to grow. You may be giving good feedback but not yet creating the conditions for it to flow in all directions.
    • Consistently Honest, 83 to 100: You care genuinely and challenge directly, the combination that produces the highest trust and best outcomes. This is rare. The priority now is explicitly teaching this approach to other leaders and making it a team-wide practice.

    Sources named in this diagnostic

    • Scott, K. (2017) Radical Candor: Be a Kick-Ass Boss Without Losing Your Humanity. New York: St. Martin's Press.
    • Stone, D. and Heen, S. (2014) Thanks for the Feedback: The Science and Art of Receiving Feedback Well. New York: Viking.
    • Zenger, J. and Folkman, J. (2014) 'Your Employees Want the Negative Feedback You Hate to Give', Harvard Business Review, January.

    Where to take the next step

    Our management development programmes build practical skills, confidence and capability for managers and leaders.

    Explore Management Development

    Frequently asked questions

    What does the Honest Feedback Self-Assessment measure?

    The most common leadership communication failure is being too nice to be useful: caring about people so much that you withhold the honest feedback they need to grow. Effective leadership communication requires two things working together — genuine care for the person, and the courage to challenge them directly. This diagnostic helps you understand where you are strong across both dimensions and what to change to communicate with both honesty and genuine care.

    How many questions are in the Honest Feedback Self-Assessment?

    It contains 20 questions grouped into 4 dimensions: Caring Personally, Challenging Directly, Feedback Quality & Honesty, Building a Feedback Culture.

    How is the Honest Feedback Self-Assessment scored?

    Responses are scored within each section and totalled across the diagnostic. The total is compared with the configured interpretation bands.

    What happens after I complete the Honest Feedback Self-Assessment?

    After the required items are answered, the existing first-name and email gate is shown before the results are displayed. The result includes an overall interpretation, section scores and development guidance.

    More to explore

    You can change your cookie preference at any time by clearing your browser's local storage.