People need to know how they are doing, what is expected and where to develop. Organisations need fair ways to recognise strong performance and address weak performance.
The annual review often fails at both. Gallup found only 14% of employees strongly agree that their performance reviews inspire them to improve.
Why annual reviews fail
Memory is unreliable. Recent events and a few vivid moments dominate year-end judgements.
Ratings are inconsistent. Different managers rate the same performance differently. That undermines fairness.
They look backwards. People hear about a period they cannot change. Linking the review to pay makes admitting development needs feel risky.
Kluger and DeNisi's review found that over a third of feedback interventions actually decreased performance. Feedback aimed at the person, rather than the task, did most harm.
What the evidence supports
More frequent conversations. Short, regular, forward-looking check-ins work better than one annual event.
Separate development from evaluation. When one conversation covers pay and growth, growth gets crowded out. Keep them distinct.
Build on strengths. Anchor feedback in what the person does well. Address gaps within that wider picture.
Invest in managers. Rock, Davis and Jones argue that ratings can make people defensive, and that regular, good-quality conversations matter more.
Build this capability in your organisation
Growth Performance designs bespoke programmes that turn insight into measurable behaviour change.
Performance in AI-changed work
AI makes output easy to inflate. A 2026 study of 962 US desk workers found 38% had received AI "workslop" from colleagues. Polished content that does not move the work forward should not count as performance.
AI also intensifies work. Ranganathan and Ye found a faster pace, broader scope and longer hours. Check whether goals still fit the workload.
Rewards need updating too. Microsoft's 2026 Work Trend Index found only 13% of AI users are rewarded for reinvention when results are not met.
Redesigning what good work looks like, and how it is checked, is Adaptation.
Practical steps
Train managers in regular feedback and development conversations.
Simplify the process to free time for the conversations that matter.
Set norms for how often check-ins happen and what they cover.
Measure outcomes such as quality and rework, alongside volume.
Try this
Replace your next status update with a 20-minute check-in. Ask: what is going well, what is getting in the way and what support would help?
Then take the free Feedback Fitness Assessment.
